Precious Knowledge = Precious Minds
The Arizona State Superintendent, Tom Horne, made a public announcement which called on the "Tucson Unified School District to shut down the Ethnic Studies Program and start teaching kids to treat each other as individuals, not on the basis of what race they were born into. The chanting behind us illustrates the rudeness they teach to their kids." When a person of power gets up to address the public before him, I believe it is respect that for your audience that should be present. This man spoke extremely disrespectfully to this crowd. He showed ignorance. The following quote speaks volumes.
"Ignorance is always afraid of change."
It is evident in the documentary that these teachers have passion about what/who/why they are teaching these students about their past. Students like "Gilbert", another highlighted student, states, "When you grow up in a poor area, you don't have the same chances as the others do." Once in the Ethnic Studies Program, he began bringing articles of interest home to read again for a second or third time. His interest grew and it flowed over into other courses. Students became engaged learners, thinkers, and producers. This connects with the article written by Gloria Anzaldua, La conciencia de la mestiza, Towards a New Consciousness. She claims that we need to know and understand one another to build unity. She speaks of "a confluence of two or more genetic streams "crossing over" this mixture of races, rather than resulting in an inferior being, provides hybrid progeny...with a rich gene pool. This "alien" consciousness is of the Borderlands." This is also true of classrooms. When students learn to know and understand others backgrounds, they form more of an understanding/appreciation for one another, bonds will form and a community shapes itself...in the classroom.
The root to a successful future for our students starts with us, their teachers. We need to provide the "hope for the Gilberts" of the world. Just like in Jeffrey Duncan-Andrade's article Hope Required When Growing Roses in Concrete,where teachers give students a voice, a reason to join in, engage in critical thinking debates/conversations and give students a HOPE for their future.
Hi Susan!
ReplyDeleteTom Horne's comment about the chanting during his press conference disturbed me just as much as it did you. The blatant disregard for the feelings and perspective of people powerfully influenced by these programs is evident. He didn't even go visit the classroom after being invited because the teachers and students could "change" what was being done that day. He was never going to give them a chance to plead their case and made his racism very clear.
The students that the documentary followed were amazing individuals who deserved to be heard.
When it comes to being "American" this country is very isolating and inflexible. Even when Tom Horne was giving his press conference the sign "Pledge In English Only" speaks volumes. While this documentary was filmed in 2011, I could see this exact scenario playing out today.
Carly, I was shocked at the blatant disregard for the audience in front of Tom Horne when he spoke. The sign was telltale, "Pledge in English Only." I feel a strong connection to our current situation here in Providence. They say they care about the children, but what are they presently doing....pulling our support coaches from every building to go cover for the VLA students that "the Network" did NOT PREPARE for! They have no Special Education teachers. They have not enough teachers. They CANNOT take our MLL coaches because that would violate the DOJ mandates. This is a sin. There is no regard for "our students" as a whole. My favorite saying comes to mind and I must share it....If you fail to prepare...prepare to fail.
DeleteYou say you believe that Tom Horne was afraid of what students could learn/gain from Raza studies; in her blog (link below), Mia said "what Horne had heard when MLK was speaking [at the March on Washington] was not about children being judged for their color, but what I believe is that Horne thought the solution to racism was colorblindness." I'm not certain where on the spectrum between the two of you I fall, but I'm curious what you make of her stance on Tom Horne.
ReplyDeleteHannah, I do believe that Tom Horne had a fear of minorities gaining knowledge to put them into positions of power some day. I went to Mia's blog and read her position on his MLK speech reference. I too believe that the statement "the solution to racism was color blindness" is extremely arrogant as well as ignorant. When you don't see color, you also don't see the hard times, struggles, and difficult times that minorities go through on a regular basis. You are turning a blind eye to the facts of reality. I'm not sure if he made that comment to ease over the fact that he was closing down a program that showed great progress in Latino students' studies. I think maybe he was trying to defend his "whiteness" so the people wouldn't be so angry with his decision to close that program down. I believe both our opinions speak to the truth of what happened in our understanding of the film.
Delete